Guide

How to find your real Instagram competitors

By Fract7 min read

Ask most people who their Instagram competitors are and they name the two biggest accounts in their field. Those accounts are inspiring, but they are rarely useful to study. Their audience, budget and history are so different from yours that their results don't tell you what would work on your account.

A useful competitor list is short, specific and a little surprising. This guide shows how to build one in an afternoon and what to do with it afterwards.

What makes an account a real competitor

A real competitor passes three tests. If an account fails two of them, it is an inspiration, not a competitor, and it belongs on a different list.

  1. Shared audience: the people you want to reach already follow it, or would. Ask yourself whether your ideal follower would recognise the account.
  2. Similar offer: a customer could reasonably choose them instead of you. For a creator, that means competing for the same attention with similar content; for a business, competing for the same purchase.
  3. Comparable stage: somewhere between a third of your size and five times your size. Close enough that what works for them could plausibly work for you.

Five places to find them

  • Your own followers: open the profiles of people who comment on your posts and see which accounts in your field they also follow. Repeated names are strong candidates.
  • Suggested accounts: when you open a competitor you already know, Instagram suggests similar profiles. Follow the chain two or three steps.
  • Hashtags and keywords: search the words a customer would use, not industry jargon, and note the smaller accounts that show up repeatedly in the results.
  • Local and offline rivals: if you have a physical business, the shop across town that customers mention is a competitor even if its Instagram is small.
  • Your customers: ask a few who else they looked at before choosing you. The answers are often accounts you have never seen.

Cut the list to five

You will probably end up with fifteen or twenty names. Score each against the three tests, from 0 to 2 per test, and keep the five highest. Five is enough to see patterns and few enough to check in ten minutes a week. Keep the rest in a note; you can swap accounts in later if one goes quiet or changes direction.

What to watch each week

Studying competitors is not about copying posts. It is about noticing what they test, what keeps working for them, and what their audience responds to. For each account, note:

  • Formats: which mix of Reels, carousels and single images they use, and whether it is changing.
  • Repeated topics: anything they come back to every few weeks is probably working for them.
  • Their own outliers: posts that did far better than that account's usual level. Comparing a post with the account's own average matters more than raw numbers, because a small account's outlier is invisible next to a big account's average post.
  • Hooks: how their best posts open, in the first line or the first second.
  • Calls to action: what they ask people to do, and which requests get responses in the comments.

Mistakes that waste the research

  • Judging by follower count alone. Followers can be old, bought or inactive; what an account's audience does with recent posts tells you more.
  • Watching only the posts that went viral. A single hit is often luck; a format that does steadily well for months is a pattern you can learn from.
  • Tracking too many accounts. Twenty profiles become noise you stop reading after two weeks.
  • Forgetting to look at what they stopped doing. A format a competitor quietly dropped is often one that didn't work for them.

Turn observations into tests

Once a month, look at your notes and write two tests for your own account, each based on a pattern you saw in at least two competitors. For example: "Three of my five competitors post a weekly before and after. I'll try four weekly before and after carousels and compare saves with my usual carousels." A test needs a format, a time window and the number you will compare. Without those, it is just a vague intention.

Keep what you learn from competitors in proportion. Their results tell you what is worth trying, not what will work for you. Your own audit, such as the one in How to audit your Instagram account in 15 minutes, tells you where your account is weakest, and that should decide which test you run first.

Competitor research checklist

  • Each account passes at least two of the three tests: audience, offer, stage
  • Candidates found from followers, suggestions, keywords, local rivals and customers
  • List cut to five, with the rest kept in reserve
  • Formats, repeated topics, outliers, hooks and calls to action noted weekly
  • Outliers judged against the account's own average, not raw numbers
  • Two tests a month, each with a format, a time window and a number to compare
  • List reviewed every quarter

If you would rather not keep the spreadsheet yourself, VERA's competitor analysis checks tracked accounts every day and flags their outlier posts against their own averages.

Questions people ask

How many competitors should I track?
Five is a good number: enough to see patterns, few enough to review in about ten minutes a week.
Should I track the biggest account in my niche?
As inspiration, yes. As a competitor, usually not: its audience and stage are too different for its results to predict yours.
Is it okay to copy a competitor's post?
No. Use their results to decide what to test, then make it your own. Copied posts rarely work twice and damage trust.
How often should I change the list?
Review it every three months, or sooner if an account goes quiet or changes direction.

See what to fix on your own profile

Every new account gets a free starter pack, no credit card required. Paste a public profile link and read the result in a minute or two.

VERA
©2026 VERA · Azerbaijan